杏吧原创

Review: The joy of symmetry

Justin Mullins asks if books about the beauty of mathematics can ever be page-turners

WHAT keeps you turning the pages of a book long into the early hours of the morning? The Da Vinci Code, for example, grips you with an unexplained death and a secret the church has hidden for two millennia. How can a book about mathematics compete?

What the authors promise in The Equation that Couldn鈥檛 be Solved and Fearless Symmetry is mathematical beauty 鈥 to be more precise, a tour of the beautiful but mysterious world of symmetry. Stick with us, they say, and for a few hours of your time, we will show you a hidden world of unadulterated mathematical magnificence.

鈥淥ne of the greatest secrets of maths is its hidden beauty鈥

One of the greatest secrets of mathematics is its hidden beauty. It doesn鈥檛 reveal itself to every mathematical traveller, though. As students, most of us take a dreary tour of basic arithmetic and calculus. That is a bit like going around Vatican City without getting off the bus. You will get a glimpse of St Peter鈥檚 Basilica but you鈥檒l miss the Gallery of Maps, Da Vinci鈥檚 portrait of Saint Jerome and the Sistine Chapel.

If you want to see these, you are better off hiring a guide to tell you their story and explain their hidden meanings. That鈥檚 the role astrophysicist Mario Livio takes in The Equation that Couldn鈥檛 be Solved. Livio鈥檚 book is largely about the world of algebra and how it was discovered. It is a neighbourhood that you would have passed through briefly in your youth, so you might be familiar with the quadratic equation ax2 + bx + c = 0. With a bit of mathematical sleight of hand it is possible to show that the solution is:

What about equations of the form ax3 + bx2 + cx + d = 0? Can these 鈥渃ubic鈥 equations be solved in the same way? Yes, as can quartics where the largest term is ax4 But something strange happens with quintics, in which the largest term is raised to the power of 5. Mathematicians puzzled over quintics for centuries, until a young Frenchman called 脡variste Galois discovered how symmetry unlocks the door to this mathematical landscape. Galois was never able to build on his discovery as, in a story that Dan Brown would be proud of, he died at the age of 21 in a duel over a woman who had spurned his advances.

Review: The joy of symmetry

Livio is a knowledgeable guide who reveals a part of the mathematical world of symmetry that most people would be unlikely to find on their own. When he reaches the domain of professional mathematicians, Livio relies on his skills as a storyteller to describe the parts of the landscape that are beyond our reach. Still, unless you have travelled there yourself, you will never really know what it is like.

In Fearless Symmetry, Avner Ash and Robert Gross make one of the bravest attempts yet to guide the mathematical novitiate up the highest mountains in the world of symmetry. Ash and Gross are not satisfied with merely telling us what it is like at the summit, they actually attempt to take us there, a task akin to taking day-trippers up Everest.

They guide us skilfully through the foothills 鈥 in the form of group theory, the language of symmetry 鈥 but most of the book is an attempt on the summit. Here they show how to use symmetry to study equations such as the quintic. From the summit, Ash and Gross even point out the frontiers of the land that mathematicians are struggling to explore today.

By its nature, the ground is hard, and even with Ash and Gross鈥檚 light-hearted help and thoughtful shortcuts, it is easy to lose your way. The truth is that many readers may not make it to the summit on their first attempt. That doesn鈥檛 matter. The view from the top is spectacular but from halfway up, it鈥檚 pretty good too.

The Equation that Couldn鈥檛 be Solved

Mario Livio

Simon & Schuster/Souvenir Press

Fearless Symmetry

Avner Ash and Robert Gross

Princeton University Press