Read more: 鈥�Unbreakable: Eight codes we can鈥檛 crack鈥�
At the US Central Intelligence Agency鈥檚 headquarters in Langley, Virginia, there is a monument to secrecy that has vexed both professional and amateur codebreakers for over two decades.
Erected in 1990, the Kryptos sculpture is a copper artwork bearing 1735 coded letters. Its creator is American artist , who received cryptography training from a CIA code expert. The sculpture鈥檚 code is divided into four sections. Three have been broken, revealing enigmatic messages that hint at a wider mystery, but the fourth and final section has yet to be cracked.
Advertisement
Sanborn has hinted that the clues to unlocking it lie in the first three sections, which a Californian computer scientist named Jim Gillogly announced he had solved in 1999. (Shortly after, the CIA announced that one of their analysts, David Stein, had solved the same sections in 1998, with pencil and paper.)
The first two sections were encrypted using a modified form of a . This draws on the same basic principles of letter-for-letter substitution as basic codes like Caesar ciphers in which, say, B equals A, C equals B and so on. However, the Vigen猫re technique encrypts letters by placing alphabets in a grid, called a tabula recta. Each letter in the message could be encoded using any one of 26 different columns.
Like many codes, to crack it you need first to find a secret keyword. This word doesn鈥檛 reveal the message by itself, but it tells you which column to use to decipher each letter of the code (see diagram).
In the case of the modified Vigen猫re used in Kryptos, the keywords KRYPTOS and PALIMPSEST told the crackers a procedure for rearranging the alphabets in the tabula recta. These keywords were discovered by a combination of letter frequency, clues written into in the sculpture and trial-and-error.
The sculpture鈥檚 first section translates into the message: 鈥淏etween subtle shading and the absence of light lies the nuance of iqlusion.鈥� The second section 鈥� which also contains deliberate spelling mistakes 鈥� hints at the .
A different method was used to reveal the message in the . Before it could be decoded, every fourth column of letters in the sculpture itself first had to be shifted to the left, then the rows shuffled. The solution was an adaptation of Howard Carter鈥檚 of the opening of Tutankhamun鈥檚 tomb.
Plenty of speculation surrounds how these answers and coding methods might relate to the unsolved final part, but nobody has yet worked out the answer. In November 2010, Sanborn revealed the solution for six of the letters in the unsolved code: 鈥淏erlin鈥�.
鈥淚t had been a long time, and a lot of people needed some encouragement,鈥� Sanborn told New 杏吧原创. His website received about 10,000 guesses in the first few weeks after the announcement, but the pace has since slowed down to about 10 solutions per day. Sanborn says many people make random guesses at the underlying message.
Others are taking a more reasoned approach. Robert Matson, a member of the largest , recently found a way to yield 鈥淏erlin鈥� from the code, using a Vigen猫re method. The solution does not, however, give intelligible text for the rest of the unsolved code, leading some to suspect that there is either another layer of encryption, or that it鈥檚 a blind alley.
, co-leader of the group, seeks clues in Sanborn鈥檚 other artworks. The sculptor鈥檚 , for example, depicts two codes, one written in the Russian alphabet, the other a near-identical copy of the coded sections featured in Kryptos. 鈥淎ny time I travel, I check to see if there are any Jim Sanborn works in the area,鈥� she says.
She might be onto something. When Sanborn created the decor for at the Spy Museum in Washington DC, he hid references to Kryptos and his other works. Before it was deciphered in 2003, the solution to his coded sculpture called went unnoticed on the wall. It was the partial text of a KGB document.
Such methods may have to suffice: Sanborn says he鈥檚 not announcing more clues any time soon. 鈥淚t鈥檚 going to only be once every decade or two,鈥� he says.
Read previous article: 鈥�Unbreakable: The MIT time-lock puzzle鈥�
Read next article: 鈥�Unbreakable: The Voynich manuscript鈥�
